Global Yacht Guide
Research guide

Boat Value 2026: NADA, BUC and What Each Number Means

Which boat value to trust: how NADA, BUC and broker comparables differ, why a lender and an insurer disagree, and what actually moves the figure.

By GlobalYachtGuide Editorial · Updated September 7, 2026 · 10 min read

A classic motor yacht berthed in a Mediterranean harbour

Quick answer: There is no single boat value, which is why NADA, BUC and a broker’s comparables can all be right and all disagree. There is a value for an insurer, a value for a lender, a value for a court and a value for a buyer, and a competent surveyor will produce different figures for each on the same hull. The first question in any valuation is who is going to rely on it.

Who Is the Valuation Written For?

Somebody specific, always. A valuation is not a property of the vessel in the way that length or displacement is; it is a professional opinion prepared for a named reader with a named purpose, and the purpose shapes both the method and the figure. Reports that do not state their purpose are the ones to distrust.

That is why a seller holding an insurance document and a lender’s assessment finds two different numbers and concludes that one of them must be wrong. Both can be right. They were answering different questions.

ReaderQuestion being answered
UnderwriterWhat sum should be paid on a total loss?
LenderWhat can be recovered if this loan defaults?
Court or executorWhat was fair market value on a given date?
Customs or tax authorityWhat value does the transaction attract duty on?
BuyerWhat is this worth in today’s market?

Why Does an Insurer’s Figure Differ From a Buyer’s?

Because it is written to replace, not to trade. An agreed value policy fixes the sum insured with the underwriter in advance, and that figure is paid on a total loss without further argument. It reflects what putting the owner back in an equivalent position would cost, which is not the same as what the boat would fetch on a slow Tuesday.

The alternative is an actual cash value policy, which pays market value at the time of loss with depreciation applied. That produces a lower and more variable number and a lower premium. Sellers should never take either figure as a guide to asking price.

Policy basisWhat it paysEffect on the number
Agreed valueThe sum fixed in advanceHigher, stable, costs more
Actual cash valueMarket value at the date of lossLower, variable, costs less

What Does a Lender’s Number Reflect?

Downside, mostly. A lender is valuing its own recovery position rather than the boat’s charm, so the figure it works from is deliberately conservative and assumes a sale under time pressure rather than a patient marketing campaign. Loan-to-value ratios then apply on top of that already cautious number.

For a seller this matters in one specific situation: when the buyer’s finance comes in short. A deal agreed at a market price can stall because the lender’s valuation does not support the advance, and the gap has to be closed by the buyer’s deposit or by the price. Knowing that in advance is worth more than arguing about it later.

Which Methods Do Surveyors Actually Use?

Three, and the choice follows the evidence available. Comparable sales is the default for production yachts because a functioning brokerage market supplies closed transactions to work from, which is the same evidence base our yacht pricing guide uses for asking prices.

Where comparables do not exist the surveyor falls back. A replacement cost approach estimates what building or sourcing an equivalent would cost, less depreciation, and it is the usual method for custom or unusual vessels. An income approach applies where the boat earns, which in practice means commercially operated charter tonnage with a documented revenue history.

MethodWhen it applies
Sales comparisonProduction yachts with an active brokerage market
Replacement cost less depreciationCustom, rare or one-off vessels
Income capitalisationCommercially operated charter yachts
A blend, with reasoning statedWhere no single method is sufficient

Who Is Qualified to Write One?

An accredited marine surveyor, and the accreditation is checkable. In the United States two bodies carry recognition: the Society of Accredited Marine Surveyors, whose accredited members use the AMS designation, and the National Association of Marine Surveyors, whose certified members use NAMS-CMS. Formal appraisal work is commonly written to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

Those letters do real work in a dispute. A valuation from an accredited surveyor written to a recognised standard is evidence; an opinion from a broker with an interest in the transaction is a negotiating position, and a court, a lender or an underwriter will treat them very differently.

  • Confirm the surveyor’s accreditation directly with the issuing body.
  • Ask which standard the report is written to.
  • Establish whether the surveyor has any interest in the transaction.
  • Check the surveyor’s experience with the specific vessel type and size.

Need a valuation somebody else will rely on?

Tell us what the number is for, whether it is insurance, finance, probate or a dispute, and where the boat lies. We will introduce accredited marine surveyors who write to the right standard.

What Triggers a Valuation You Did Not Ask For?

Age and value thresholds set by other people. Underwriters commonly require a condition and valuation survey once a hull reaches 20 years, and then at intervals of 5 years from the last survey date, with a new policy accepting a survey up to 2 years old. Agreed value cover can bring that requirement forward, with some insurers asking from 15 years.

Published underwriting guidance also uses size and value together: a formal survey where the boat is over 20 years old, 30 feet or longer, or insured for $50,000 and above. None of those thresholds is universal, and all of them mean the same thing for an owner, which is that the valuation date arrives whether or not a sale is planned.

TriggerCommon threshold
First insurance surveyAround 20 years of age
Repeat intervalEvery 5 years from the last survey
Survey age accepted on a new policyUp to 2 years
Agreed value coverSometimes from 15 years
Size and value testsOver 30 feet, or insured above $50,000

How Does a Valuation Shape a Loan?

Through the term as much as the amount. Marine lenders run 10 to 20 year terms with 15 years common on mid-size vessels, and the loan-to-value ratio interacts with that: published examples show a 90% advance capped nearer 12 years while an 80% advance on the same boat reaches 15. The valuation sets the base that both numbers apply to.

For a seller the practical consequence is that a buyer’s monthly payment, and therefore their budget, moves with the surveyor’s figure rather than with the agreed price. Our yacht appraisal guide covers what to expect from the visit itself.

When Is a Formal Valuation Worth Paying For?

When a third party has to act on the figure. Financing, insurance placement, probate, divorce, a customs position and any dispute all involve someone who was not at the negotiation relying on the number, and that reliance is exactly what a signed report from an accredited surveyor provides.

Setting an asking price does not qualify. That is a commercial decision, informed by closed comparables and by where the boat needs to sit in the search results, and paying for a formal appraisal to make it is spending money on the wrong instrument.

SituationFormal valuation needed?
Applying for financeYes, to the lender’s specification
Placing or renewing insurance above a thresholdYes, usually with a condition survey
Probate, divorce or a partnership dissolutionYes, to a defined standard and date
Setting an asking priceNo, use closed comparables
Settling a customs or duty positionYes, and take tax advice alongside

What Does the Report Have to Contain?

Enough for someone else to follow the reasoning. A valuation that states a figure without showing how it was reached is not usable by a lender or a court, and a surveyor who works to a recognised standard will not produce one.

  • The purpose, and the party the report is addressed to.
  • The effective date of the valuation, which is not the date of the visit.
  • The method used, and why it was chosen over the alternatives.
  • The comparable evidence, or the cost basis, set out in full.
  • The condition findings that informed the adjustments.
  • The surveyor’s accreditation, and any limiting conditions.

Our yacht survey checklist covers the condition side of the same visit, which frequently happens at the same haul-out.

How Do You Build a Comparable Set?

From transactions that closed, not from boats still for sale. A listing records what one seller hoped to receive; a closed sale records what a buyer actually agreed to pay. Building a price from live listings means calibrating against the unsold, which is the group you are trying not to join.

Aim for at least 5 closed sales of the same model or a genuinely equivalent one, recent enough that the market has not moved underneath them. Where the model is rare, widen the definition and adjust explicitly rather than pretending three sales are a pattern.

  • Collect closed transactions, with dates, from a broker with access to the data.
  • Match on model, year and general specification before anything else.
  • Note where each boat was lying, because location moves price.
  • Record engine hours and major equipment, which are the two largest adjustments.
  • Discard anything more than about 18 months old unless the market has been flat.

Should You Price High to Leave Room?

Not by much, and rarely at all. Padding an asking price to create negotiating space assumes the buyer is already looking at the listing, and the padding is exactly what stops them looking. Room to negotiate is worth nothing if it costs the audience that would have made the offer.

The stronger position is a number inside the band that the comparables support, held with confidence and documented with the evidence behind it. Sellers who can show why the price is what it is negotiate better than sellers who built in a cushion and are waiting to be pushed.

A useful test: if you cannot name the five sales your price rests on, you have not priced the boat, you have guessed at it and added a margin.

What Size of Cut Actually Registers?

A cut only counts when it crosses a search threshold. Buyers search in round numbers, so the audience for a boat changes in steps rather than smoothly, and a reduction that stops short of the next threshold reaches nobody new. A move from $520,000 to $499,000 puts the boat in front of everyone filtering under half a million. A larger-looking move from $560,000 to $505,000 does not.

That reframes the arithmetic entirely. The right question is not what percentage to cut but which threshold the boat needs to be under, and what it costs to get there. Sometimes the answer is a small cut with a large effect, and sometimes it is the reverse.

MovePercentageBracket crossedEffect
$520,000 to $499,000About 4%Yes, under $500,000New audience
$560,000 to $505,000About 10%NoLittle change in reach
$310,000 to $299,000About 4%Yes, under $300,000New audience
$299,000 to $289,000About 3%NoSignals softness, adds nothing

The mechanics of choosing the original band sit in our yacht pricing guide. A listing placed just above a threshold at the start is the most common self-inflicted pricing wound in this market.

What Should You Not Use a Valuation For?

Marketing. An insurance figure quoted in a listing tells a well-advised buyer that the seller has confused two documents, and it invites a negotiation about credibility rather than about the boat. The advantages of holding a formal valuation are real in the situations above and absent in the sales conversation.

The other misuse is arithmetic. A valuation is an opinion at a date, and a boat that was valued 18 months ago in a different market has been revalued by events since, whatever the certificate says. Our yacht appraisal guide covers how often the exercise needs repeating, and the tax implications of selling a yacht page covers where a valuation becomes a tax document rather than a commercial one.

Frequently Asked Questions

Because they answer different questions for different readers. An insurer wants a figure that will replace the vessel, a lender wants one that survives a forced sale, and a buyer wants what the market is paying today. All three can be professionally defensible and none of them is the asking price.

An agreed value policy fixes the sum insured with the underwriter in advance and pays it on a total loss. An actual cash value policy pays the market value at the time of loss, with depreciation applied. The first produces a higher and more stable number, and it costs more.

An accredited marine surveyor. In the United States the recognised bodies are the Society of Accredited Marine Surveyors, whose members carry the AMS designation, and the National Association of Marine Surveyors, whose certified members carry NAMS-CMS. Formal appraisals are commonly written to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

Comparable sales for most pleasure yachts, because a functioning brokerage market supplies the evidence. A replacement cost approach is used where comparables are absent, as with unusual or custom vessels, and an income approach applies where the boat earns, which in practice means commercially operated charter tonnage.

When somebody other than you has to rely on the number. Financing, insurance placement above a certain value, probate, divorce, a customs position and any dispute all call for a signed report from an accredited surveyor. Setting an asking price does not; that is a commercial decision informed by comparables.

Sources: surveyor accreditation from the Society of Accredited Marine Surveyors and the National Association of Marine Surveyors. Appraisal standards from the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

Want this run for your own budget? Tell us what you need and how to reach you. Independent research first, then options with the real numbers behind each one.

Request a yacht buyer consultation

Share your budget, target LOA, and use case. We reply within one business day with matched brokers or surveyors.

Prefer WhatsApp? Message us on WhatsApp